Date: 2004-08-01 02:02 am (UTC)
Want a womb? Take mine. Mind, the connections aren't all there any more, since I NEVER want to be pregnant. Pregnancy, the early weeks of, in my experience (not opinion, experience) is nothing to get all excited about. I don't get excited about having the flu either - and the symptoms of both are about the same.

But with regards to the fact I'm not all 'connected' - I've got a tubal ligation. Sterilization. I'm 'fixed'. And you know how HARD that was to get done? At 24, nobody says 'Are you sure you won't change your mind' if you decide to make the permanent decision to have a child. But at 24 a doctor feels perfectly justified in TELLING someone who wants to make the (possibly reversable) decision never to have children that she's too young and too stupid to know what she wants. It's a procedure that is covered by the NHS here in the UK for the few people the doctors accept as 'mature' enough to make the decision. I wound up having to pay over a thousand dollars (converted) to have it done at a private clinic - but if I'd been pregnant and wanting antenatal care, I'd have had no costs and no problems.

That's still not personal experience, Dracono. That's a secondhand account, and you don't know what was going on 100%. From my third-hand perspective, it sounds like the boy decided he WANTED the baby - and the girl did NOT want the pregnancy. Maybe someone clued the girl in to how difficult adoption processes can be. Maybe her parents found out and took her to the clinic themselves. Maybe she decided she didn't want to be pressured into giving birth to a baby she couldn't support, be pregnant and have to drop out of school, or generally ruin her life. And maybe she didn't want to tell him because she knew him well enough.

And you know what? He made a mistake in killing himself. His decision to kill himself might well have been what made her kill herself. But what would he have done if she'd miscarried?

My problem with your argument, that it's a human being when it's got its own DNA, is that, really, a tapeworm ALSO has its own DNA. Is it acceptable to you for me to worm my cats? It's not an actual human being until it's viable outside of the parasite existence - say, five or six months along? I mean, a tapeworm's alive, too. It's got DNA and a nervous system and everything. What if *I* had a tapeworm? To me, it's just a matter of the type of parasitism.

I never said a blastocyst/embryo doesn't have a nervous system - it's developing. I said a blastocyst/embryo is not sentient and aware. Trees ARE 'aware' in a way I can't quite describe - they're aware when they're being fed upon by another animal and can produce anti-feedant chemicals, for example. And chopping a tree down doesn't necessarily kill it. For that matter, cows and chickens are aware - and I'd say that, in their own way, they're also sentient. Doesn't stop me from eating them.
This account has disabled anonymous posting.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

Profile

athelind: (Default)
athelind

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

November 2019

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
101112 13141516
17 181920212223
24252627282930

Tags

Page generated Jul. 13th, 2025 01:09 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios